Thank you. We're going to start in a minute, everyone. Thank you. All right, let's get started! so Thank you. All right, hello everyone. I'm Philippe Pasquier, I'll be the moderator for this session today. The next session is Artist Perspectives. Every year, the Expanded Conference, since we are at Ars Electronica, Every year, the Expanded Conference, since we are at Ars Electronica, invites the award winners of the new animation art jury to present their work in front of the Expanded Conference audience. And so we are in for a treat today. We have three guests, two honorable mention winners, and then the golden Nika winner. And so let's get started without further ado. We'll have 30 minutes for each speaker, probably a 20-minute presentation, and then hopefully a little bit of time to interact so that you get to ask your questions to them. The first speaker today will be Rayat Yazbik. The first speaker today will be Raiat Yazbik. Raiat is a US-based visual artist investigating how technological infrastructures mediate collective memory, ethics, and public life through archival research and collaborative practice. Against the backdrop of AI, pervasive surveillance, andlit mondial, Yesbik explore notre système de forme computationnelle, de forme computationnelle, de forme non seulement de ce que nous voyons, mais aussi de comment nous nous souvenons, nous bougeons et nous gardons des témoignages. S'il vous plaît. Is this on? Yes, it is. Okay. Hello. Hi, everybody. My name is Riot Yesbik. So today my talk is titled God Was My First Encounter With Surveillance Technologies. And I apologize, I'm going to be reading a little bit, so thank you for bearing with me. When I was a child, I was often haunted by the idea that God was watching me. I understandably misconstrued the intended protective clause in that well-trodden phrase, God is watching over me, and was fearful that he would see me in my entirety, that he would perceive my queerness, my trans being, my homosexuality, or as the Pentecostal Catholic Church I had been raised in deemed it my deviancy, and he would cast me out of a circle of safety and belonging. I remember lying awake at night in bed fearful that he might appear before me only to chide me for my incongruent thoughts. During my youth, a profound dissonance existed between my longing for communal acceptance and the unsettling conviction that I remained an outsider. I became adept at performing a sanctioned identity to maintain social cohesion and to feel safe in my environment. forming a sanctioned identity to maintain social cohesion and to feel safe in my environment. My actions driven by a persistent dread that an omniscient judgmental deity was monitoring my every move. God was my first encounter with surveillance technologies. My childhood beliefs were enough to keep me in line and in accordance with the church for much of my young adult life. And it wasn't until I went to college and began to study cultural anthropology and visual art that my understanding of surveillance technologies began to take shape as I started to deconstruct belief systems that kept me from understanding myself for so long. I have since dedicated my artistic life to uncovering the ways in which power structures, buttressed by cultural beliefs, impact how at home we feel in our bodies. I also think it worth noting here that our current tech oligarchs use many of the same psychological fear-mongering tactics as the church leaders of my youth. To save oneself is to fall in line with dominant ideology and get on board before it's too late. So as I mentioned, I was trained in cultural anthropology, so my background is really in looking at structures, structures of oppression, looking at culture as a set of beliefs, systems, ideas, tools. And I'm also trained in studio art, so I approach image making as a form of research, a method for reproducing knowledge about how power operates through visual culture, particularly in the U.S. From this position, I examine how surveillance infrastructures, state, corporate, and algorithmic shape collective memory and govern the legibility of personhood through documentary filmmaking, performance, installation, computational media, drawing, and sculpture. Rather than treating surveillance as a purely technological phenomenon, I understand it as a cultural formation, a set of images, habits, and instructions that shape how people move, comply, and imagine themselves in relation to power. So I'm gonna start kind of with earlier work because we were asked to give you an overview of our practice and I'll get to the project that I have here at the end. But this is actually a piece I started making in 2015 in grad school. So I was particularly interested in the intersections between gun violence, patriarchy, and capitalism and power and working through and reimagining symbols of violence as sites of intimacy or as new forms of embodied flesh as seen here in this project entitled Grip. Here I fabricated a firearm made out of a flesh-colored silicone and then I took a series of photographs that kind of used that silicone dildo gun as a way of creating a vernacular. I'll just play a little clip here, real short. Grip is probably one of the most underestimated or misunderstood aspects of fast shooting. And it's not so much important for accuracy, but for speed. Pulling the trigger correctly doesn't really have anything to do with how you're gripping the gun. You can pull the trigger properly and get an accurate shot. But for that quick follow-up shot or rapid fire shooting or the point shooting, if you want to get into that conversation, the grip is everything. So in that, I kind of go through, it's like about an eight minute film and I just mimic the whole thing. He talks about the beaver tang of the gun and I was like what the hell is the beaver tang? It's really strange and sexual. It's like, this is just a gun tutorial, you're like what? So anyway, so I'm kind of taking this object and imagining it not as a weapon but as a site of intimacy, tension, and embodiment. So the soft kind of fleshiness becomes, in conjunction or kind of works against the hardness and violence and control into something kind of disarmingly vulnerable and humorous. And so I play with kind of using the minute body while mimicking this sort of traditional tutorial to sort of demonstrate how to hold and stabilize a gun and collapse the boundaries between instruction, performance, parity, and critique. This is a work called not Threat Simulator, although Threat Simulator is a very fun title. So in 2014, I made a project with a private higher military style security firm located in Detroit, Michigan, which ended up being, I'm showing you very old stuff, I don't know why, but that's just what's happening, that I made while I was also in grad school. So this is another way I was thinking about surveillance, belonging, and working with individuals who kind of despite their marginalized social status end up taking on and performing the moral majority within their communities as a kind of threat management strategy. So for this, I did a 50-minute film with a company called Detroit Threat Management Center and the owner, Dale Brown. And I went on a 50-minute ride-along, surveillance community ride-along thing with him and his Hummer. So he's decked out in tactical gear and I kind of show up mimicking him in tactical gear. And what unfolds is like about an hour-long piece that really examines kind of everything from his relationship to morality, to civic engagement, to violence, to racial histories. So and he's also a black man kind of doing this work in Detroit, Michigan. So the piece kind of really explores that tension of his personal embodiment as a black man also surveilling kind of black communities while also trying to then counter the work he's doing by then also showing up to offer free self-defense training to those same people. So I was really interested in that kind of what he was giving over, how he was complicit in these systems, but then also how he was really performing. He was really performing authority in a way that was very much so about a stage with him and his Hummer and sort of the performance of security was very much so at part in this whole project. So I'll just play a quick clip. Okay, clear. I got the door shut. We're able to return the dogs. Okay, we got them in the house. This was made in 2017. So everybody on my team can see it out in the field. So I can actually see what it is that they're doing as well at all times. So what I created was what I call interwoven fail-safes. Everyone's watching everyone. And everyone has something to do with another person's performance so there's no real way for you to get out of whack and not pay attention because someone's requires you to do something in exchange you know do something and there's constant interactions right there's no time for someone to deviate say um sneak off and go home or not protect when they should be. And that's also a psychological tactic. It is. And they generate their own psychological proof of their performance. Care to record. Time is 7.20pm. Hello, how's it going sir? Everything okay? Time is 7.20 p.m. Hello, how's it going, sir? Everything okay? Everything okay? So what was really kind of of interest to me in doing this work with him was really understanding he had a very big philosophy around the psychology of surveillance. And he had no real right authority you see him there stopping someone at the end and filming them with his iPad right asking what he's what he's doing in that area and I said well why did you stop that guy and he's like well because I don't know that license plate and I don't know who that is right and so he can't really do anything in those instances but this intimidation factor was something, and understanding his psychology behind how he was using performance, the visual aesthetics, right, of military gear and garb as a way of doing his work was something I wanted to understand. So that piece ended up premiering in Los Angeles. Here's just a really quick image. It was in a mirrored TV frame, and so the project kind of projected, or the image, the video image projected holograms in the video in the window bays that it was out overlooking at night when it was playing. So I leave it to the American to talk about gun violence and all these things in the room but hey here we are. So another work that I did is called It's Kind of a Scary Feeling, where I was trying to tackle the feeling or the sensation of being watched head on. This is a little bit lighter, although the film, if you watch the entirety of that previous film I just showed you, there is a bit of humor in there. So this is a piece where I kind of worked with performers and sat them around various places where I've shown this project. This is at the Banff Center for Arts and Creativity, where I stage people who are typing into what looks like chat boxes on their computers, but then what they're typing is actually appearing in the space for the rest of the audience to see. And what they're doing is really I've just asked them to kind of note how people are moving through the space. So not anything specific about a person, but just how are people moving through the space. And so while the performers are kind of doing that, right, folks are coming up and also chatting to them and wanting to know what they're doing. So this is kind of a piece that plays on empirical study and really tries to draw into focus base desires and fears underlying socio-cultural knowledge production. The longing for clarity, to feel slightly removed from or above the predictability of our lives. So this piece really questions a seat of power by making empirical study itself a subject to be scrutinized. Drawing observation back in on itself, I connect how societal attempts to structure life's precarity play out in interactions online and confront us with how we create false narratives of safety, security, and fear. Here's just another image of this. You can see Vaughn there on the couch typing and some of the comments that were projected on the surrounding buildings. I also work a lot through performance and without sort of narration in it. So this is a piece that also made back in 2016 which takes two or more performers and places them in head-to-toe industrial-grade Velcro suits and masks. The performers cannot really see, and so they play out this kind of entangled web of relation in which close proximity to another performer means navigating the challenging intertwining of their physical beings and the loud sound of rupture when they part. of their physical beings and the loud sound of rupture when they part. So I was really with this just trying to kind of get at something very phenomenological, right? Something very sensory about how does it feel sometimes to be too closely intertwined with another, right? And what does that feel like in the body and in the soma? So here it is at Red Cat in Los Angeles. And just so you can hear the sound, because the sound is really something, when you have like 10 people in these suits, it's really quite, this is two people, but quite loud. Rekordverk. So this was actually at the Academy Solitude in Stuttgart, where I joined a friend there that was on residency, and we did an evening of performances titled Potentially Dangerous Contraptions that really looked at, turned that chapel, they have this beautiful chapel there with all these really adorable cherubs, and we kind of turned it into a jester court and had people sit at the edges or the parameter of the room while we sort of had these multiple different kinds of contraptions and performers using them in the interior of the space. And my friend James in the back there, James Rushford is an incredible experimental musician and did some really incredible audio work with the show. Just another example, this piece is 2023. It's titled Collision Practice. This is a piece in which my collaborators and I, we just ran at each other full speed and we had to figure out a way to catch each other while in movement. So I was really thinking about the feeling of burnout in a time of political turmoil. And how do we as communities actually show up and care for one another when we have less than optimal conditions? And so this was really, how do we figure out how to fall on something like a cement floor and catch each other and disperse that weight, right, so that the collective stays kind of relatively safe and unhurt. This, I'm just going to go quickly through this one and then I'll jump to the current project. This piece was called And Laid Him on the Green. This was 2019, right before the pandemic in Melbourne. This piece, for this work, it was a three-channel, a multi-channel installation and live opera with four live vocalists where we examined how misheard speech functions in courtrooms. So we were actually, I spoke with a forensic audio analyst in the U.S. who then kind of walked me through what her work was and her job was. And she really kind of began to tell me how in courtrooms her work was being overridden for police testimony and the inherent problems with that. And she was also sort of walking me through about how easy it is to be primed to hear something from another person that's actually not being said. So this whole piece kind of examines truth as it operates within the U.S. court system, but also within how we interpret and hear one another. I'll just play a really short clip from this. When you are recording, you get that 60 hertz line. If someone chops it, cuts it, to like, I killed her, or I did not kill her and takes away the knot you will see a break in that line and that is how we for something that is fake and that is how we spot that something is fake right, there are still tools for that. That said, a company came out with a tool. I don't even know why they bothered to make it. But they claim we cannot tell if audio has been edited with their tool. They claim to have something that allegedly hides all edits. So when you are combining all that, you are giving the illusion to the brain that there is something there that isn't. Is that something you come across frequently? Police or prosecutors tampering with recorded evidence? I've come across it a couple of times. The most recent one was a high-profile case in Chicago. He was a gentleman who was in jail for 26 years for a crime he said he didn't commit. I'm just going to pause that there. So we were really trying to sort of experiment with looking at misheard speech, what's barely caught, residual moments occurring at the intersection of technical capture and human interpretation, and what gets lost in those spaces. Excuse me. Okay, so the work that I'll be performing tomorrow evening at 6 p.m., I believe at the JKU Med Space, I'm pretty sure, is called The Innocence of Unknowing. And this project is, I completed this in 2025, premiered it at Tribeca, and have been touring it since. did this in 2025, premiered it at Tribeca, and have been touring it since. And for this project, what I did is I took a news media archive that I personally amassed since 2019. And I downloaded clips off of YouTube of news coverage of mass shootings in the United States. And I created about an 800 plus news media archive that I then worked with a collaborator, so a friend of mine who's very technically brilliant, Milo Tawani, to actually create a bespoke AI in 2023 that was capable of analyzing and indexing and editing this archive and every second of footage in this archive from the viewpoint of a humanities scholar and personally an abolitionist is what we really kind of asked it to give us. So here are some of the texts that we actually trained it on. Admittedly, they were a drop in the bucket compared to the LLM and another open source software we used to create our AI. But when we really got into kind of granular analysis with the AI around what was happening in the footage, we could ask it very specifically, well, what would Susan Sontag see happening in this very particular clip at five seconds and, you know, or five minutes and 32 seconds. So it allowed us to parse really specific analysis about this archival footage. Key to this project, and this is a gauze and splat here, you can see, as we recreated gauze and splats from the archival footage. This one was done with performers in a park. But key to this piece for me was really looking at this very specific posture as an entry point into examining what I call choreographies of retreat, or choreographies that are created by police and military to move the public during times of crisis. So this piece really actually looks at it. It starts in the 60s and goes to present day, and it examines the rise of the surveillance state within this very specific archive. I'll just play a few seconds, but then hopefully you'll come to the performance tomorrow night. Aurora, why are people hiding in plain sight? The people are likely hiding from the source of the gunfire or the potential for further violence. The act of seeking cover indicates a perceived threat to their safety. What are the sources of gunfire? Who is creating the potential for further violence? What threats to their safety do you perceive? The people hiding in plain sight are reacting to a situation of extreme danger. But their actions can also be interpreted as a reflection of a society where fear of state violence is normalized. There is gunfire everywhere. So I'm just going to pause that there. So the piece is an hour and a half, and it consists of a live conversation with this AI, with myself and the AI. It also screens as a feature film, and I also have a shorter version, which I'll be sharing tomorrow night. So here are some of the places it's shown. And it also showed at this gallery, Reising and Taylor in Los Angeles, where I had the ability to take some of the objects that are featured in the film, such as these pieces of chalk in the shape of firearms that are used to make this drawing that you see at the end of the film, which I'll show you shortly, and actually install those in the space. So here you can see it's marbled chalk pieces of firearm that actually work as writing tools. So here they are used for the performance. So I asked folks at a residency I was at to draw out what they typically see and associate with as the key players in a mass shooting as seen on the news media. And they ended up creating this piece at the end. And so this is kind of the final image of the film, and through this image I'm really thinking about how do we move past these current systems and failures that we have, societal failures, move past these current surveillance systems that we have, so that we can start to see these things as somewhat of a cave painting, right, as something of a bygone past. So, thank you. gone past. So thank you. Oh, and I also teach at Arizona State University's LA-based campus, Narrative and Emerging Media. We do have really generous funding. So if you want to come study with us, we have a 4D Gaussian splat rig. Yes. All right. So we have time. Don't go too far. Don't go anywhere, in fact. If you can stay with us. We have time for questions. Yeah. No worries. Any questions from the audience? Otherwise I will get us started. Oh, there's one at the back. Am I on? I'll ask a question. Thank you so much for the generous talk. And I think, you know, it's very provocative dealing with mass shootings in the United States. And so I suppose, from your perspective, there's a lot of conversation right now around, like, common-sense legislation in dealing with this stuff. You know, like, There's many good ideas, I think, just to even require insurance on weapons or things of this nature. But what do you... So by entering this work into the public zeitgeist and having a conversation around gun violence, is it your hope to begin to pause for reflection in this space, or do you just want to simply have a conversation around it? Yeah, thanks for that. I mean, I'll be honest, what I'm really trying to do with this project, it is about mass shootings, but really, and you'll see if you come tomorrow night to the performance, it really is an examination of the police state. So the project doesn't focus at all on the shooters. I'm not at all interested in the terrible conversation of the shooter's psyche, which places all the onus on the individual and does not look at societal and systemic failures. So this is a structural essay film that wants to say, here are the systemic failures beyond the ones that we already know, which is like common sense gun reform, blah, blah, blah, you know, like just get rid of the guns. So what I'm actually trying to do in the project is look at and trace through kind of movement and through that hands-up position the rise of the police state and how we as residents of that country or anyone passing through that country who gets caught in the crosshairs of these things forfeits their rights within those moments right because to raise your hands is to assume you're guilty you have to be proven innocent so at one point in the film the AI actually thinks the cops are arresting all the victims right and so we use that as a springboard to discuss why. So I think that there's, you know, there's things like that I want people to be thinking about. I want people to think about who it benefits that this has been allowed to go on for so long. Similarly, like I want people to think about who does it benefit for us to believe that AI is going to kill us all, right? So it's like there are real things at stake in the ways that these discourses get framed and they create frenzy and they make people feel ungrounded and we know that people don't make good decisions when they feel that way. So I hope that answers your question. Otherwise, I didn't know your work, and it's really a rich, dense body of work. And to me, running through it, there's this tension or articulation between the visible and the invisible, the internalization of beliefs and the sensation of being watched, perceived oppression, and the self-monitoring that results from it, whether it's through religion and God's eyes or with those CCTV cameras. So do you see contemporary algorithm surveillance as producing a self kind of self monitoring? Is that where you're going with the title? Yeah, I do think, yeah, exactly. I mean, I think this is a very Foucauldian title in the sense of, right, thinking about this panopticon that watches us all the time and we don't actually have to see or know how it works. It's just the feeling or the knowledge that we are being watched produces a series of compliant behaviors. And I think that now, while we know those surveillance apparatus exist, I'm interested in what happens when we internalize that and we live that. What do we lose by living that? So yes, totally what your question is spot on. Any other questions, anyone? We still have a few minutes left if needed. Then my second question was about the fact that you showed us more than 20 years of work. You started in showing us work from 2015. And there's really consistency that I could perceive, but what did change, and can you reflect on the longitudinal arc throughout this work, and maybe the new kid on the block is this AI? Yes, it is the new kid on the block. I mean, I think as an artist, right, sometimes your making and ideas come to you and you have no idea why you're making what you're making. And I think that's a beauty of making work is you trust the process and you keep going. And then you end up realizing like, oh, I've been dealing with the fact that I feel threatened and I hate feeling threatened. And how do I manage that as a human being? And my work is about that, right? And so then when something like AI pops up, and we have these very inequitable, right, these inequalities so deeply ingrained within this new technology, unfortunately, that could have really other beautiful applications. You know, my first go-to is how can I think about and talk about this within a cultural context that holds salience right now in relation to the things that I know well, which is this kind of understanding, just as I mentioned in the beginning, of knowing how to hide a little bit in plain sight as a kid in a community you're not wanted in. Awesome. Let's thank our speaker once more, and don't forget to go to the performance tomorrow. That's really why we have you here. Thank you. Thank you so much, you guys. Our second speaker in this artistic perspective session is Veneta Androva, which I welcome on stage now, with a Bulgarian visual artist and filmmaker based in Berlin, working across CGI animation, speculative documentary, moving image, and installation. A practice explores our technological infrastructure, artificial intelligence, once again, and automated media shape perception media shapes perception and systems of knowledge and political imagination the floor is yours Hello everybody. Thank you for the invitation. Very happy to be here and present some works. I was asked to speak about my practice more broadly today rather than about one specific project. Much of my work begins with subjects that resist direct access, things that cannot be entered, observed, or documented in any straightforward way. This resistance is where the idea of speculative evidence comes from, the title of this talk. My background is in fine arts, with earlier studies in history of art and philosophy, and my practice is rooted in experimental documentary. I use CGI and game engines to construct spaces where different forms of documentary material can be brought into relation. For me, speculation is not an alternative to evidence. It is a way of working with this distance between what can be documented and what can be known. I would like to start with an older work, Oasis, from 2018. I began working with experimental documentary during my studies in Berlin on an exchange at the Academy in Jerusalem. I started researching on the Wazis Casino in Jericho. Eventually, this became my diploma film and in many ways the starting point for the practice I'm showing you today. It's a complex story, so I'll try to keep it short. The casino opened in 1998 after the Oslo Accords, one of the first major international investments in the West Bank. It was promoted not only as an economic project, but as a kind of a peace project, creating exchange between Israelis and Palestinians. And at the same time, it was surrounded by a controversy over corruption and who actually benefited economically. With the second intifada in 2000, the casino closed, but strangely it remained equipped and guarded around the clock, essentially waiting for a political situation in which Israeli visitors might return. This is the official statement. When I arrived in 2016, it had been closed for 16 years. Nothing had been removed, nothing had changed. It was simply waiting. So the manager said from the international group, they don't want anyone good to go inside like journalist Anyone else but you can take your pictures from outside the street And yeah, this is what happened several times I kept trying to get inside to understand place, research the history, but I kept running into restrictions. So I worked with what I could access, interviews with formal staff, taxi drivers, people in Jericho and a lot of archive footage from when the casino was operating. The gap between what I could research and what I could actually observe became the starting point for the film and the form of the film. I turned to a game engine for the first time and built a digital desert, almost like a walking simulator. As you move through it, fragments of documentary material appear along the way and gradually form the story. There was another limitation. At that time, as a student, I couldn't afford the license fees for much of the archival footage I had collected, so I started working with audio description instead, using descriptions made for blind and visually impaired audiences. Here on the right, you see the original archive footage. It never appears in the film, only the description does. Jericho City Views. Pan to Intercontinental Hotel. Tilt down to Casino. Back to the checkpoint of the entrance of the city. Soldiers in Watchtower. Soldiers walking around. I did the same with people I interviewed or people from the archives that painted portraits from from from this material and I play like the film stills and I place them as objects in the environment the animation was minimal the voices remained untouched as original recordings. As you walk through, you meet each one of them and it gives you a fragment of the whole story. And this is also some material from the film. I think it might do something to the peace and will let Israelis come into this territory so maybe it will help with all the peace process. I think it's a great idea. this territory so maybe it will help with all the peace process. I think it's a great idea. And since Waze is, game engines have become my tool for constructing spaces where fragments from very different sources and different kinds of documentary material can exist in relation to one another. The next project I'm going to show you from my desert from 2019 moved into a different kind of sealed world. The art market and the free port is one of its most extreme expressions. Free ports are highly secured storage facilities operating under special custom and tax regimes where artworks can be held traded and resold as financial assets often without leaving the building. What interested me was the speculative logic behind this. The object can remain physically still while ownership and value continue to circulate and the artwork becomes both a cultural object and an asset for a financial speculation. The free port was also a space that could only be known from the outside through a very limited set of representations. What was publicly available were fragments like this here that you see, documented footage, reports, photographs and descriptions. I used this material as a reference, not to reconstruct the report precisely but to build a fictional version from the visual information that was available to me. On the left, it's an actual viewing room from the Geneva Freeport which I specifically research on and on the right it's my reconstruction. The documentary image becomes material rather than a model to reproduce. The free pot also opens onto a broader question of accumulation, value preserved in order to generate more value. This is where Max Weber's writing on the Protestant ethic and capitalism enters the film, particularly the link he draws between restraint, accumulation, and reinvestment. Luther enters the film not only as a historical figure, but as an image reproduced and circulated on a massive scale through portraits from Lucas Cranach the Elder and his workshop. On the left, you see Cranach's portrait, work from, and on the right is my painted version. And Luther's dialogue comes entirely from his own letters. I constructed the script bringing sentences from different letters together, and he sometimes signed his letters from my desert, and this became the title of the film, a fitting image for a painting sealed away in a free pot, I think. The film becomes rather later, it becomes rather a strange love story between an art investor and a portrait of Martin Luther that he has acquired. The narration droves on the conventions of erotic audiobooks, another form that I adapted for this film, shifting the language of intimacy onto financial transaction. As the collector becomes attached to Luther and refuses to resell him, the logic of accumulation and reinvestment begins to break down. And this is a short excerpt. You have already enough, and I do not short expert you have already enough and I do not see why you long so for me or why my services are so necessary to you the young investor didn't have an answer for that either Cheers. He was so unrelenting. just by hearing him speaking. You could swear he saw through the thin fabric of his robe, the manly shape of his chest, and felt the cramps deep inside him, in the hot, dark places. The next work, Ava, is from 2020 and was presented here at A.I. Sectronic in 2021. Ava takes the form of a documentary about a fictional female AI artist. She's developed by a team of male engineers to produce artworks that are then exhibited and sold. The project began with the real phenomena, the emergence of humanoid robot artists and the language used to present them. One important starting point was Ada, a humanoid robot artist initiated by the galleries AIDA and Mela and developed with a team of engineers. What interested me was the construction of authorship around her. AIDA is presented as a female artist with creative agency, while her production depends on the human technical economic apparatus behind the scene, and who construct the artist who speaks for her and who ultimately owns and profits from her work. This connected to my research into gender structure in both art and technology and to the much older model of the male artistic genius and the female muse. Rather than documenting Ada, I constructed another artist, Ava. And Ava became a fictional subject through which I could examine these structures. Ava's studio is also based on this famous image of Gaya Critic's castings, 1819, the painting of Caspar David Friedrich in his studio, the first image depicting an artist's studio and the figure of the male artistic genius. I use its composition but reverse the gaze. Instead of the male artist observing the world, Ava studies the male body. She analyzes the male figure through datasets and categories such as the hero, the genius, the warrior, the athlete, filtering familiar cultural stereotypes through the position of a constructed female robot artist. It will take me 45 minutes to sketch the figure. I am keenly aware that the pose in Newt painting is first related with gesture. The posture, if standing or sitting is influenced by gravity. So first I am very patient to my male muse. I generously wait till he goes through his search for the perfectly balanced gesture. This is interesting, the male figure in its perfection. A masculine heroism. the male figure in its perfection, a masculine heroism. I have so much information about that specific concept in my database. This could be something. So this was Ava working. And now we move to the project that I'm showing this year at AS Electronica. It will be screened today, 2 p.m. at MedSpace. You're all welcome to join me for the screening and Q&A. I will try to keep it short here. It's a work that I took almost three years of research. This here is an installation view from the Bulgarian Pavilion in Venice, Pinal, this year. And the film begins with a phenomenon that emerged in Bulgaria around 2022, so-called mushroom websites. These were news-like websites that could appear quickly, publishing large volumes of copied, slightly modified content. The same article could circulate across dozens of apparently separate sites, often with little accountable editorial structure behind them. From there the content moves into social media groups, private chats, other channels, and what interested me was not simply whether the individual story is true or false, but the infrastructure that allowed it to circulate, how content moves, who amplifies it and who profits from that movement. And this infrastructure was not limited to Bulgaria. Similar networks operate internationally, often through sites that appear to belong to completely different national context. Here, for example, the same content appears on Pollen's and Belgians' business model known as information laundering. As content moves across apparently independent sources, its origin becomes harder to trace, while repetition can give it an appearance of legitimacy. And this brought me to a broader question that runs through the film, the gap between information and knowledge. Something can circulate as factual information while being detached from its source context and accountability. And during the research, I found a Bulgarian platform called Share4Pay. It allowed practically anyone to create a mushroom website by just signing up with an email address and in 30 minutes everything was ready and online. So I registered myself and this was unimportant to my research to could enter the infrastructure from the inside. This is the dashboard showing visits, advertising, statistics and earnings. The website wasn't simply a publishing tool, it was designed as a system in which circulation could be directly transferred into money. And here is an explanation how commissions and payment worked. Very simple, publish content, generate traffic, receive advertising revenue. There was even a partner system in which users could earn commissions by recruiting others. And this infrastructure was also visible at the technical level. Research by Todor Galev at the Center for the Study of Democracy traced shared advertising scripts and networks, infrastructure across multiple mushroom websites. And apparently independent domains were connected through the same advertising system, revealing a shared infrastructure of monetization. So what looked like a shared infrastructure of monetization. So what looked like a dispersed landscape of separate websites is on another level economically and technically interconnected. One of these traces led me to advertising platform AdRain. During the research part of this infrastructure began to disappear so I had to work with traces on the way back machine. This became heresoristic for the whole project and the process. The system was never visible as a whole, only through its traces, websites, source code, archival pages, domain registration, interfaces, headlines, testimonies and monitoring data. The subject emerged through the connections between them. I also tested the content itself together with Svetomila Mikhailova, a machine learning expert at Aalto University. I analyzed collected headlines using models developed by GATE Institute in Sofia and trade in Bulgarian language which was very important for the project. We tested for three things signals of human machine autoship, likelihood of disinformation and sentiment of emotion based persuasion. The results suggested patterns rather than proving anything. These outputs enter the film alongside the headlines themselves. The mushroom character is a fictional composite who speaks entirely through headlines collected during the research from mushroom websites, he gives this dispersed archive a body and a voice in that way. And since responsibility in this infrastructure is deliberately distributed, so I was less interested in identifying individuals than in the positions they occupy within the system. The human characters are therefore composites built from roles, relationships, emails, and other traces I found. And their pixelated faces borrow the language of documentary anonymization but reverse its logic. The anonymity itself is constructed. but reverse its logic, the anonymity itself is constructed. So I performed all the voices myself, then reshaped them with synthetic voice models based on samples contributed by participants. And this is how I think about construction more broadly. The materials already exist, each with its own history and authorship, and what I construct are the relations between them. So, to return to the title, speculative evidence, across these works, what interested me is not only what can be documented, but what can be known from fragments that remain. An image, testimony, an interface, a data set. None of this speaks from outside the system that produced it. It each carries the limits of its own perspectives and the traces of its authorship, whether human, institutional, or algorithmic. Speculation is how I work with those limits, not to overcome them, but to make them part of the form, keeping visible the conditions under which knowledge is produced, and by whom and or by what. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And so let's open the floor for questions. Any questions, comments from the audience at this stage? Otherwise, I will get us started. The Prius Electronica, and this is in the catalog, has the chance to have 4,500 somewhat applicants and they compile statistics because when you have big numbers like that you can do that and it turns out, and I was kind of shocked by that, but it's pretty apparent if you roam the festival that more than 50% of the artists presenting at Ars or submitting at Ars are using AI in the making of their work, often as well as AI as a protagonist or as a topic in the work. And so my first question for you would be, with generative AI, we can now evidently construct extremely plausible visual evidence almost instantaneously. And so does it threaten your idea of construction as a documentary method? Does it force us to establish new criteria for what you call speculative evidence can legitimately claim to know? What do you see this articulation between your notion of speculative evidence and what's happening with Gen AI? Yeah, thank you for that question. between your notion of speculative evidence and what's happening with Gen AI? Yeah, thank you for that question. It's actually this question was the starting point of this last project that I'm showing this year here. It started with the question if machine generated text is detectable. And question if machine generated text is detectable. Yes, and then there was this rabbit hole with no exit. And during the research with Zetomil Mihailov, who is a computational linguist, and we tried several ways to approach that question but at the end in the film and during my like during these three years that I also thought about that a lot it turned like in the film at the end this part and this question became a forensic trace simply somehow I mean we have the results of what percentage this text could be generated by a human or not, or the persuasion and so on, but at the end, it wasn't about that. So I think that, yeah, generative AI could make things faster, technologically much more smoother. It's getting absolutely impossible to detect text, for example. I mean, we now speak also about hybrid text, like almost no text is only human or machine anymore. And about like video is still very much detectable. Other visuals like just an image could be very difficult as well. And at some point I think it's not about that anymore. And with the speed AI technology is developing, it's just a cat and mouse game. So this shouldn't be the starting point to approach that topic. Interesting. It's in 2025 that the amount of text, AI-generated synthetic text online, reached the amount of human-made text, and since then we have, as you just mentioned, issues to track things down because we can't tell no more, interestingly. So throughout your work, because you presented more than what the screening will show at 2 p.m., there's this theme of, I feel, of resisting opacity, and you make great effort into what you call your research, which is research, really, and you accumulate those traces, those fragments, those speculative evidence. So I have a two-fold question, maybe three-fold question for you. Can you elaborate on... Did this notion of speculative evidence have been changing for you throughout the years? And then, once more, as generative AI makes synthetic image increasingly cheap and convincing, does the idea of speculative evidence become more politically risky? And the third part of that question is sort of a reformulation. What prevents speculation from reproducing the very opacity that you're trying to critique in the first place? the very opacity that you're trying to critique in the first place? Yeah, well, I started, as I mentioned in the talk, with experimental documentary. And in a way it was also assembling reality. Approaching documentary experimentally, my approach was different, but in the essence I was assembling reality or making connections, relations visible so that I can create a glimpse of some reality. And sure, there is this notion of speculative, like with the generative AI, with the generative AI, how reality is being assembled and mediated, the generative AI just plays a huge, massive role. And it's, of course, political. And in that sense, yeah, it is a shift there. But I think the shift is just in the frequency and in the speed, not in the pipeline. And can you remind me the third part of this question? The third part is, does this... Okay, let me go back to my notes here. The third part is, does this prevent or does it reproduce, therefore, the very opacity you're trying to critique? Degenerative AI? Yeah. Or no, the notion of speculative evidence that you put forward, because now it's speculative, the AI itself is the easy, ongoing, infinite, unstoppable speculation. And so do you find a tension there, or do you find it has been pushing you somewhere else in your research? Yeah, well, it's opened totally different possibilities that are developing so fast that it's like, it's opening up a door with an endless possibility of working with trace, like reconstruct, construct. It became, it's just, yeah, it's a massive tool. So I think that what I meant with pipeline in that sense was just like how a piece of information could, or a piece, a perspective on some reality could be mediated and produced and constructed. This pipeline stays the same. It's just the tools are changing, and they're changing super quickly at the moment. And it's used, of course, from many actors, and this makes it political and urgent to think about that. Thank you. Let's thank our speaker. And this makes it political and urgent to think about that. Thank you. Let's thank our speaker. And our third speaker in this artistic perspectives session, after having heard from the two honorary is none other than the golden knicker of the new animation art category, Andrew Herzog. Andrew Herzog is a US-based interdisciplinary artist whose media independent practice explores the constricted boundaries between humanity and nature. In doing so, he examines the perceived liminal space between human and non-human life across personal and species-specific temporalities. Andrew, the floor is yours. Thank you. I have to choose my content. All right, here we go. Okay, thank you, everybody, for being here. Happy to be speaking to you today at Ars Electronica and showing my film work that's both showing at Lentos, and then we'll have a screening tomorrow. I'll talk a little bit more about that in a moment. Much like my two fellow artists, I'll talk a little bit more about that in a moment. Much like my two fellow artists, I'll talk a little bit about my body of work and perhaps how it has led up to the work that I'm showing here. So for me, my background is in art and design. I did a brief stint for two years at the Google Creative Lab in New York City. So while I do have a background in design and technology as well as art, the work that I make most often and the work that I'll talk about more today has more to do with ideas of how humans interface with the rest of the natural world. So as was kind of briefly mentioned, I work as a artist who I describe myself as medium agnostic. So I don't necessarily work in any one specific medium. I work in painting, sculpture, video, ephemeral works, all of the above, participatory works. And I think at the core of all of these things that I'm thinking about, that I'm working on, is this idea of where and how do humans sort of compartmentalize themselves from the rest of the natural world, and ultimately what might be and what are now as we live in the effects of the conclusions to that, or the logical conclusion to that ideology of separating ourselves through technology, through our relationships with other people, many multifaceted ways. So to kind of ground some of this, I wanted to talk a little bit about, do a brief etymology lesson, which I'm sure all of you are familiar with, etymology, the study of language, not to be confused with entomology, which is the study of bugs, although they are quite similar in their wording. But I wanted to talk a little bit about this word garden, and specifically about the English word garden, which in the late 1400s into the 1500s, in the English language, and more specifically, I think, sort of postured in the West, there's this idea, or the word garden goes from a noun, goes from a place, and more specifically I think sort of postured in the West, there's this idea or the word garden goes from a noun, goes from a place to a verb. It goes to a way of constructing, a way of organizing, delineating space. And why I think that's important is because there's a moment here in time that also coincides with sort of fall of Christianity into sort of secular humanism and the sciences kind of rising in the 1500s. But this idea that we're no longer part of nature, but actually we are in control of nature. We have this ability to then shape and form it. So inherently it sort of makes us, differentiates ourselves from it. And ultimately I think it becomes this like way in which first we can delineate ourselves from the rest of the natural world, but as humans then we start to be able to delineate ourselves from each other, right? We say black from white, male from female, who you love, what religion you practice, all of these sorts of things. And I think that as a sort of stepping off point, which was not started in the 1500s, but I think perhaps presides us with an interesting small moment in time to think about the way in which language can change these relationships and ultimately set us on a track in our history to what I think a lot of things that we're dealing with now are products of. This is a small quote from Timothy Morton who's a contemporary philosopher but I think he really captures this well in a piece of writing where he's talking about climate change. And he says, in order for humans to acknowledge climate change, we first need to stop being racist, sexist, xenophobic, homophobic, transphobic, etc., etc. And essentially, he's talking about exactly what I'm talking about in this way, that if we can't see or we can't sort of understand the way in which we compartmentalize ourselves, other humans from other humans, then there's no way that we can then pick up the sort of murmurs and understandings that the natural world is providing us to understand what's going on with the climate and the rest of things in the world. So in my work, I'm often thinking about this idea or this sort of like liminal space. This is a work from 2016 where on spring mornings early in New York City, I would go around and much like the people who wheat paste posters and advertisements and things like that, instead of wheat pasting advertisements, I was wheat pasting moss onto objects and things around New York City. So if you were in Brooklyn or in New York City in that time walking around, for a couple of weeks you might have seen moss growing on what was the north side of all of these objects based on the sort of wise tale, the folklore that moss grows only on the north side of all of these objects based on the sort of wise tale, the folklore that moss grows only on the north side of things. So this small sort of pseudo technological moment where people if they understood or had a relationship to the natural world in that way, it becomes a navigational device, it becomes something that's akin to Google Maps or Apple Maps if you're a masochist. So this project went on for a few weeks until I ran out of moss. It received various strange recognition from people walking around on the streets wondering why there's moss showing up on things. around on the streets wondering why there's moths showing up on things. But I think the reason why I show this kind of older work is I think it maybe perhaps does a good job of underpinning, I think, what I'm kind of getting at with this idea of this liminal space and this way in which we can kind of interface with nature as a way to sort of navigate our world, quite literally. as a way to sort of navigate our world quite literally. A little later on I made this video work here which kind of dealt with my upbringing is one that was from a family that's more blue-collar working-class. I didn't go to art museums or galleries or things like that when I was a kid. So when I went to art school, there was sort of this process of learning about everything to do with art. And for a while, I think I've always kind of tried to understand the relationship of art and the sort of prominence that it's given in the world. So in 2017 and 2018, I was doing a lot of work that was related to the idea of drawing and ways in which we could draw ephemerally in spaces like this where we're using snow as a means to draw. But thinking about things that we all kind of have access to or things that we're all kind of like afforded as beings who live here on the planet, who interact and interface with the natural world. Which brings me to a project in 2019 where that subject matter that I was interested in utilizing was the sky because we all have the sky above us, we all relate to it, we all use it to kind of understand weather, to understand what time of day it is, things like that. So this project was commissioned by the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia. It consisted of these four structures that had these about a meter, a little over a meter by a meter, mirrors on them that have these four blue dots that are kind of these different saturation points of blue that at different points of the day, they kind of match the color of the sky and seemingly disappear. So over the course of the day, you might see one that feels very distinct or different from the sky color, and then later of the day, you might see one that feels very distinct or different from the sky color, and then later in the day, you might find that it actually matches the sky color almost seamlessly. So these dots kind of disappear, and in a way, it kind of, for me, served as this very rudimentary technology, rudimentary augmented reality to a certain extent, in same way that we're placing with our phones perhaps an image into a space. We could use these sort of static means to see things that were changing around us, things that are kind of constantly in motion that we might not be thinking about as constantly in motion. So it stayed in Philadelphia for 2019 and then has since found a home in a private collection on the coast of Oregon. So now it kind of lives here out with the mountains and the trees and watches the sky out there. Which is quite nice. In 2020, as with probably all of us, there was this kind of time during the pandemic where everything kind of went seemingly insular to a certain extent. And I am based in New York City, but left New York City to go back to the town that I grew up in basically with my partner and during that time kind of interested in obviously continuing to make work, but the means to do so is a little bit less in terms of making public work or public art so started to work on a project that for me was one that I was kind of interested in in terms of gardening and in terms of that for me was one that I was kind of interested in in terms of gardening and in terms of planting flowers. And so I made this work called These Things Take Time where I planted a group of native wildflowers on a walking path that was a circle in this big field in the spring and then watched it grow throughout the year until the summertime when we had this kind of nice little yellow brick road, yellow walking path that existed in this kind of verdant green space. And this is a quick look at the whole thing. So it was maybe about 200 meters all the way around, so not super big, but big enough to walk around and kind of an interesting project in terms of this relationship with the rest of the natural world and you know native plants in general it's also an interesting work in terms of after the course of the year from planting to kind of growing and then I harvested some of the plants to make ink from to do paintings with but to see the life cycle of an artwork, to see an artwork go from, you know, being manifested by my human hands and then sort of taken back over by the grassy field that it was in over the course of a couple of years, now it's completely gone and is as if nothing has ever taken place there. I think it's an interesting perhaps relationship to an artwork in terms of its ephemerality and our control over it. One that I quite like and I think is often reflected in the way in which we often use technology and think about the way technology, the things that technology affords us. So this was the next year, so it came back the next year on its own, naturally, but then in the following couple of years, kind of went away. I also work a lot with land art. And I think America in particular has a very interesting relation to land art, mostly because of its sort of ideology that deals with sort of imposing structures onto the land, changing the land, altering these resources. So in my work, oftentimes these ideas of land art structures, the ideas of intervening into the land, I like to use model making as a means to kind of make that work rather than making it physically in the world or in the space that we're in. Because obviously it doesn't alter or change these things in the natural environment, but still provides, I think, an interesting fodder for ideas. And kind of like, I think, speaking of that non-interventionalist ideas, this is a work called finally, an impermanent human intervention, which is a work that was made by painting a big granite stone on the northeastern coast of the US with seawater and granite for anybody that knows when it's wet kind of has this very striking contrast it becomes a much much darker tone than when it's dry so this is just seawater that's being painted onto it the water evaporates the rock goes back to what it's supposed to look like but it was meant to kind of speak towards these sort of monumental notions and monumental gestures that have been made over the course of the last 80 years in the US and in terms of this like ideas of land art and the ways in which land artists have worked, which sort of led to a lot of work that I do kind of in the studio in my painting work, which the painting work is always sort of undergirded by a practice or methodology of using rock pigment. So I source rocks all over the place, oftentimes in the parks in New York City, and then grind them into a pigment. And then I use that pigment and water to make these rock paintings that kind of have this very seemingly rock-like quality to them because they literally are rocks which to me is kind of a nice circular idea that feels like this thing, taking a little bit of this thing to kind of create a larger version of that thing. So along with the ephemeral and sort of video and all sorts of other work that's being done, I have a practice of painting and kind of making these works as well that vary in their sizes and shapes and kind of deal with different subject matters. Oftentimes mostly just the rock shape, but other times kind of delve into just more formalist painting as well. Often these painting deals with large human structures or things like that. This is the first dino balloon at the Macy's Day Parade, first dino balloon at the Macy's Day Parade, which is one of the biggest or the earliest kind of oil, oil companies that use the Macy's Day Parade as an advertising platform. So this is the first time that they showed the dino balloon there, which has become kind of this odd, like beloved American icon like iconography so in a lot of ways I'm thinking about these sort of like moments images technologies structures objects that visualize or sort of make visual these ideas of like human scale and sort of like human continuity in terms of its relationship to the environment and nature. Which brings me to my project that's being shown here which is a project called Deer Hunter. It's a film that has sort of multiple storylines that deal with technology, masculinity, and sort of the ways in which these things become intertwined and the sort of effects as with much of my work, maybe this work is most visible or most literal and it's talking about the way in which these things become intertwined and perhaps the effects of them and in particular the ideas of masculine lineage and during the making of this film are kind of like in the process of concepting this film in 2024 as both kind of preparing for the arrival of my son who's my first child and also dealing with the terminal diagnosis of my uncle who was my godfather who was very very close with, who ended up passing away like three weeks before my son was born. So the work I think looks at sort of this multitude of ways in which identity and masculinity are sort of passed through generations and in particular for me it was important or felt important as I think about how to raise a son in this time and in this generation with things that are happening are with technology and also things that are happening governmentally in the world. So this is a little like trailer type thing for it that I'll show. Nel 20 novembre 1920 fugi dalla prima andata in vendati del fascismo. La mia familia non parlo mai piu questo lingua. I don't speak this language anymore. Where is he? Where is he? Allow me to introduce myself. I'm a hunter. The American hunter. The process of sending an American white-tailed deer abroad is complicated. There are many factors that must be considered. There are millions of American white-tailed deer across this country. What distinguishes one from another? Its size? Its age? Its disposition? What does this deer know of exceptionalism? Remember this deer will serve as an ambassador to Italy, making it the face of America. Here in Rome, the sun shines every day. I listened to recordings from our conversations last year. As we sat in the shade of the sycamore tree, he tells me he'll be here next year. But now, next year, he's not here. Only the sun and the heat persist. So as I said, that one is currently on view at Lentos and there's also some vitrines and tables that have a bunch of the research and sort of other materials that went along with the making of that that I think do also a much deeper and perhaps better job of explaining all of the details that are provided in the film. And then it's screening tomorrow at Medspace at 4.30. For those who might be interested in seeing it, and I think I'm having a conversation with Juergen after that. So very much looking forward to that. I think we're on time. Good on time? Yeah, we're perfect. Okay. I'll just show one last thing. I had the pleasure of being an artist in residence for two months in the spring this year in Vienna. And I started working on another video project that I'll show a little bit pieces of it here that is currently about an old man and a plant but in a lot of ways quite interested in this relationship or this relationships that we have with plants in our lives and particularly potted plants and the sort of like necessity of care and the the relationship of care that is not necessarily reciprocal but one that perhaps we we entertain and kind of delve into anyway so I'll end with a couple of minutes of that We're going to take some questions. The station is located on the north side of the station. Norske Ropsten Ober- und Kaisersplatz. Umsteiger Suche für 1. Perhaps worth noting that this man is real. He's not AI. The The The The So, that one will probably be developed over the next year or two into a bunch of things, but that's all I have for now. So thanks for... Let's bring our hands together for Andrew. Questions for our Golden Nika winner? Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. be with your works, with the snow and the stone water, the moss, I pretty much still see this binarity of human creativity and agency and the nature as a medium that's used. And in the beginning you said you want to break this apart, but I still see it in some way connected to Land Art of the 60s and 70s. Not much of a difference. How would you describe that? And in the beginning, you also mentioned transphobia, homophobia, and so on. How do you engage with that? Yeah, thanks for the questions. I guess with the first one, I think that, yeah, to a certain extent, you're not wrong. I think that these things live in a lineage that is perhaps rooted in the 1960s. And I think a lot of the sort of actionists and land artists and things like that that existed at that time. In some ways, I think that perhaps the differentiation or my view of how it differentiates has a bit to do with the way in which it's still utilizing the natural world or utilizing like these points of nature I think specifically in the earlier work with the the moss and things like that but to a certain, I think often for me, it's the ability for those things to perhaps exist on their own terms alongside it in a way. I think that like a lot of the work in the 1960s and 1970s and 80s, those things are being sort of thought of only in means of medium, whereas I think like some of the things are ways, at least in my perspective, my point of view, the ways that these things are being used is a little bit of both, hopefully, or could perhaps be perceived that way, but also always happy to have, you know, a sort of differentiating point of view on that. In terms of like the sort of homophobia, transphobia, those sorts of things. I mean, I think that specifically, like I guess I'm most interested in I guess I'm most interested in not necessarily making work. I wouldn't say that any of the work sort of like screams any of those things in any way. But I think that at best, perhaps they offer a sort of space in which, maybe to that point of Timothy Morton or the idea of like the change in, the means of the change in the idea of what a garden is as a place to a verb like language and the ways in which we visualize things or view things in the world, I think plays a big role in the way that people view the world and people view each other. And so I think hopefully the work maybe does something along those lines. I don't think that it's inherently like work that is specifically pointed at those subjects, but I use that kind of just as a way of framing perhaps like the long-term or the sort of the logical conclusion perhaps of some of these things or like some of these ideas when they go the opposite way or they go in a way that just perceives like human ideas as only ideas or kind of like specific in that way. Okay, thank you. And I had a question myself. In fact, the work is, the body of work is really nice in that it's serene, effortless, it feels flowy. And I had a question about the separation of human and nature, and I wanted to go Dona Araway on it, but it's been addressed already, so I won't do that. So I'm going to go to my AI question. You can see the thread here. There's a lot of that AI art which is so, so very present here and elsewhere, in which AI is effectively the subject of the work and in Deer Hunter, AI seems almost secondary to those questions of memory, masculinity, political inheritance. Do you think, and that's a very general question, masculinity, political inheritance. Do you think, and that's a very general question, that we're reaching a point where artists can finally stop making work about AI and simply use those systems as one material amongst other? What's your relationship with AI? Yeah, it's funny, we were kind of having this conversation the other day. I mean, the work still, like if you see it in its entirety, there's still, it references AI to a certain extent, maybe in a little bit, maybe not as straightforwardly as work maybe sort of felt like it needed to in years past. So I think it definitely feels like somewhere in between, like it's a work right now that exists in between this moment of like, to your point, like necessitating to say like this is a work about AI because it's made with AI and some point in the future where that is not necessarily a need anymore. I mean, I don't I don't know. It's a little hard to speculate. I think like our relationship to the technology is one that is currently constantly evolving and in the way that we think about it or the way that we accept it. So Deer Hunter, I think, deals with that or hopefully kind of speaks to that in some way. What that will turn into is sort of a question mark in my mind, whether or not we will get to a point where everything is just accepted, whether it's AI or not. We don't ask that question, we don't care about those things anymore. I don't know that, I don't know, I don't know that I'm pro that necessarily to a certain extent. Maybe. I think it will just be a matter of how things evolve and where we kind of view them and what these things turn into over the next couple of years as in terms of the way that we'll relate to them or the way that we'll accept them in terms of a means or a medium for making art or films or things like that, or whether we still need to kind of touch on the fact that this is what it is. Thank you, Andrew. So unless there's any burning question, we'll close this session here by clapping one more time. Excellent. Next in our program is in 10 minutes, so you have 10 minutes for lunch, that's the news, is the interactive brush downstairs at Deep Space 8K. And then we'll be back here at 2.30 for the Azifa Austria Forum. At 4.30, a keynote by Catherine Isbister. And so that's going to be not to be missed. And at 6.30, a party. And there will be free drinks and food. All right. Thank you, everyone. Thank you.